Commercial Real Estate is in Trouble. Climate Change Is Part of the Problem

August 21, 2023
Posted in News
August 21, 2023 veps

It’s hard to escape the sense that the old-fashioned office is in trouble these days as employees continue to work from home and some companies try to shave square footage to cut costs. Unsurprisingly, commercial real estate firms now face declining valuations and financial pressure to turn the situation around. On top of this, it turns out climate change may be playing a meaningful, if admittedly secondary, role further stressing the commercial real estate market.

Insurance costs for commercial real estate are rising rapidly across the country, outpacing rent increases and general inflation. An August Moody’s report suggests a link to climate change. The growth in the cost of insurance for multifamily properties, for example, has tracked closely with the frequency of $1 billion natural disasters in the U.S. And properties in high-risk climate zones, particularly those at risk of hurricanes, face the highest insurance rates.

Take retail properties in Miami, a city at risk of hurricanes. The Moody’s report shows that rent increased at an average rate of 1.4% between 2017 and 2022. The cost of insurance increased by 7.5%. In Denver, where wildfires rage nearby, the cost of retail rent increased by 0.4% annually in the same time frame; the cost of insurance increased by 9%. The numbers are similar in cities across the country.

It’s not just cost that’s concerning. Some commercial real estate companies are finding it hard to purchase sufficient insurance at acceptable terms. That means properties are left without enough insurance to fully cover the damage caused by a range of increasingly likely climate-related extreme weather events. The market is just beginning to process what that means. In the short term, it means that property investors and lenders take on additional risk that would have once been covered by insurance. How that will reshape commercial real estate as we experience more extreme weather in the coming years remains to be seen.

“It’s an increasingly challenging conversation because we understand there are these areas that have repeated hazards,” says Natalie Ambrosio Preudhomme, who researches the commercial real estate market for Moody’s. “And there are long-term implications for the viability of these markets and the communities that are driven by them.”

This topic has yet to enter mainstream conversation around climate and insurance, but it has been a point of discussion behind the scenes at commercial real estate industry gatherings. And potential insurance issues have shown up in regulatory filings, too. Vornado Realty Trust, a significant player in the New York City real estate market, warned this year, for example, that climate change may affect its business “by increasing the cost of (or making unavailable) property insurance on terms we find acceptable.” Other large commercial landlords, like Boston Properties and Highwood Properties, to name a couple, made similar statements.

There are ways to get ahead of such challenges. Property owners can harden their assets—think of improving drainage to prevent flooding or installing a new roof—to make them more resilient to climate-linked events, for example. Some experts are calling for insurers and regulatory bodies to offer financial incentives to make that happen faster.

source: time